Katz on Louisiana v. Callais

Ellen D. Katz (University of Michigan Law School) has posted Continuities And Departures In Louisiana v. Callais (American Journal of Law & Equality, forthcoming) on SSRN.  Here is the abstract:

Louisiana v. Callais legalized racial vote dilution in the United States. Without explicitly overturning a single precedent, the Court presented its ruling as the logical culmination of prior decisions rather than as a dramatic break from the past. This Essay examines Callais in light of this presentation. It isolates what Callais took from precedent, and shows that the ruling emerged from a series of subsidiary, sequential determinations, each rooted in prior caselaw. The Essay, however, also isolates what Callais added to the principles on which it relied and argues that ideas Callais presented as the inevitable progression of existing doctrine involved significant conceptual leaps. Callais did not acknowledge these analytical gaps, much less grapple with the paradigm shifts that follow from them. In short, the decision initiated a profound change in law and practice without defending the critical claims on which it relied or taking principled accountability for their application.

Highly Recommended!

To receive new posts from Legal Theory Blog by email, get a free subscription to Legal Theory Stack.

Lawrence Solum