B. Jessie Hill (Case Western Reserve University School of Law) has posted The Medicalization of Abortion Rights (Harvard Journal of Law & Gender) on SSRN. Here is the abstract:
In the decades between Roe v. Wade and Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, advocates brought numerous constitutional challenges throughout the country to laws restricting abortion. In general, these cases were brought by abortion clinics and providers, and they foregrounded substantive due process claims that relied heavily on medical and scientific evidence and expertise. This abortion litigation, which was carried out in a relatively centralized and coordinated fashion, was configured in this way for good strategic reasons, but it increasingly resulted in committing reproductive rights advocates to a medicalized understanding of abortion rights.
However, the medicalization of abortion rights has had troubling long-term doctrinal and political effects, resulting at least in part from its failure to center the pregnant individuals who are most affected by abortion restrictions. It situated control with medical professionals rather than the affected individuals, thus sidelining religious freedom and equality-based arguments. It may have been incompatible with other advocacy frameworks, such as reproductive justice, that prioritize the voices and needs of pregnant individuals. In the wake of Dobbs, this Article argues that advocates may benefit from a more flexible approach, strategically alternating between medical and non-medical framings and including a wider range of claims and plaintiffs. This approach could address past limitations of medicalization, fostering an abortion rights discourse that is more grounded in individual autonomy and dignity.
To receive new posts from Legal Theory Blog by email, get a free subscription to Legal Theory Stack.
Lawrence Solum
