Mikhail on Free Exercise of Religion

John Mikhail (Georgetown University – Law Center) has posted The Free Exercise of Religion: An American Perspective (Matthias Mahlmann and Hubert Rottleuthner, eds., Ein neur Kampf der Religionen? Staat, Recht und religiose Toleranz (Duncker & Humboldt, Berlin)) on SSRN. Here is the abstract:

How should a constitutional democracy treat the religious beliefs and practices of its members? In January 2005, I gave a public lecture on this topic in Germany as part of a year-long lecture series on religious tolerance (“Ein Neuer Kampf Der Religionen? Staat, Recht und religiose Toleranz”) hosted by the Freie Universitat Berlin. The lecture was subsequently published in a volume of comparative legal essays edited by Matthias Mahlmann and Hubert Rottleuthner. In my contribution to this volume, the only chapter written by an American, I first sketch the history and main contours of American free exercise jurisprudence. I then consider how that jurisprudence might apply to one controversy that has generated considerable debate in Europe: laws which regulate or ban the wearing of Islamic headscarves or other conspicuously religious attire by students in public schools. In brief, I argue that while U.S. sconstitutional protections of religious liberty are comparatively weak, at least by certain European standards, the probable effect of American doctrines of free expression, neutrality, and anti-discrimination would be to render laws such as the French headscarf ban constitutionally suspect.