Bonneau & Stricko-Neubauer on Supreme Court Continuity & Change

Chris W. Bonneau and Tara W Stricko-Neubauer (University of Pittsburgh – Department of Political Science) have posted The United States Supreme Court: Continuity and Change (American Politics 5, pp. 107-123, 2006) on SSRN. There is no abstract, but here is a taste from the introduction:

The United States Supreme Court is a judicial institution unlike any other in the world. The Court sits at the pinnacle of the American judicial system and is a powerful court of last resort with extensive discretionary powers of judicial review. Additionally, Supreme Court justices are institutionally insulated from the political process and the Court itself enjoys high levels of public support and confidence despite its lack of electoral accountability (Caldeira and Gibson 1992; Durr, Martin, and Wolbrecht 2000). Generally speaking, when the Court makes a decision the majority of the American public and political leaders accept it as legally binding even if they disagree with the substance of the decision.

During the last few years there has been no shortage of important and politically relevant judicial decisions. The Court has made noteworthy rulings in areas of traditional importance including the death penalty, free speech, and voting rights. However, the Court has also shown a willingness to assert its legal authority in areas of contemporary political controversy. Court decisions on the rights of criminal detainees, the rights of homosexuals, and school vouchers are clear examples of this fact.

In this chapter, we examine some of the Supreme Court’s most important decisions over the period of the George W. Bush presidency, focusing especially on the 2001 to 2005 terms.