Smith & Tuttle on Church Autonomy and Co-Religionist Hiring

Peter J. Smith (George Washington University – Law School) and Robert W. Tuttle (George Washington University Law School) have posted The Union Gospel Mission Cases, Church Autonomy, and Co-Religionist Hiring: A Response to Professor Esbeck on SSRN.  Here is the abstract:

Courts have increasingly applied a doctrine of church autonomy to resolve claims involving religious organizations. A recent decision of the Ninth Circuit invoked the doctrine to permit religious employers to favor co-religionists in hiring, even for non-ministerial positions. Professor Carl Esbeck has written a thoughtful critique of the court’s decision. This essay responds to Esbeck and, more broadly, provides a criticism of church autonomy doctrine and a roadmap for decision when the Ninth Circuit’s opinion is reviewed en banc. In our view, courts should apply a doctrine of ecclesiastical abstention, which prevents them from resolving specifically religious questions. But we do not think that the Religion Clauses are properly read to confer broad decision-making immunity on religious organizations even when resolution of claims would not require adjudication of any religious question.

To receive new posts from Legal Theory Blog by email, get a free subscription to Legal Theory Stack.

Lawrence Solum