Lewis on Legal Positivism, Context-Sensitivity, and Crummey’s Principle of Legality

Sebastian Lewis (University of Surrey) has posted Legal Positivism, Context-Sensitivity, and Crummey’s Principle of Legality on SSRN.  Here is the abstract:

This paper engages with Conor Crummey’s The Principle of Legality: A Moral Theory, which reinterprets the principle of legality through Dworkinian integrity. It makes two main claims. First, Crummey mischaracterises legal positivism: positivism is not defined by a commitment to conceptual analysis. Second, his proposal that legal obligation is always and necessarily context-sensitive carries serious costs. It generates pervasive legal indeterminacy and undermines law’s role as a shared, public standard for planning and accountability, which is one of the moral reasons for positivism.

Recommended!

To receive new posts from Legal Theory Blog by email, get a free subscription to Legal Theory Stack.

Lawrence Solum