Liau on Res Inter Alios Acta and Mitigation as Methods of Increasing Damages

Timothy Liau (London School of Economics – Law School) has posted Res Inter Alios Acta and Mitigation as Methods of Increasing Damages on SSRN.  Here is the abstract:

This chapter examines a recent controversial case, The Skyros. The Skyros has forced the courts to value the claimant shipowners’ contractual right to timely performance, independent of any consequential loss. It is a good litmus test nicely showing how competing explanations of ‘damages without loss’ must depart.

There, ‘res inter alios acta’ emerged as an independent ‘principle’ for assessing damages for breach of contract. The Court of Appeal’s attempt to formulate an independent res inter alios acta principle resembles in key respects Summers’ model of policy-minimalist, causation-based mitigation, in Mitigation in the Law of Damages (OUP 2025). In the interests of coherence, a ‘res inter alios acta principle’ is probably not the best way forward. It is ambiguous and unstable. It may be that the latin phrase tracks a specific sense of ‘privity’, but privity is complex, and it is better not to add to that complexity.

It is argued that: (1) the ambiguous phrase res inter alios acta, which has come to be used as a synonym for ‘collateral’, was used in different senses at different stages. The High Court had in mind the sale price for the ships received by the owners, while the Court of Appeal thought it was the owners’ contractual obligation not to charter the ships out again. This instability in the Latin tag makes it productive of doctrinal confusion; and (2) properly understood, mitigation cannot apply to justify the award made on those facts. How res inter alios acta and mitigation could operate, curiously, as methods of increasing damages above a claimant’s factual loss, will be discussed, as this helps us to better understand and test the limits of ‘mitigation’ as an explanation for damages without factual loss, one of the striking and controversial features of Summers’ thesis.

Recommended!

To receive new posts from Legal Theory Blog by email, get a free subscription to Legal Theory Stack.

Lawrence Solum