Riles on Law’s Failures Annelise

Riles on Law’s Failures
Annelise Riles (Cornell University) has posted Law’s Failures: Means and Ends on SSRN. Here is the very interesting abstract:

    This paper treats the general sense of failure that pervades the field of Conflicts of Laws as an opportunity to consider how failure generally might be understood in the law. Through an analysis of the field’s history as compared to the history of property law, the paper argues that Conflicts’ failure stems not from its inability to identify with either a normative or an instrumental theory of law, but from a failure of aesthetic technique. This analysis stands against both a normative understanding of law that sees Conflicts as having failed because it lends no substantive support to any claims of political or social effect on the one hand and an instrumentalist view of law that finds Conflicts doctrines unworkable, and unable to produce predictable or desirable effects. The wider goal of the paper is to draw serious theoretical attention to the technical character of legal knowledge. The “failure” of Conflicts as a field, however, also invites attention to the conditions under which this technical aesthetic ceases to captivate the imaginations and commitments of legal theorists, teachers and practitioners.