Powell on Buck v. Bell at One Hundred

Robyn Powell (Stetson University College of Law) has posted Bucking Bell: Anticipatory Regulation and Disabled Family Life a Century After Buck v. Bell (New York University Journal of Legislation and Public Policy, forthcoming) on SSRN.  Here is the abstract:

In 2027, Buck v. Bell turns one hundred. The temptation will be to mark the centennial as the anniversary of a wrong the law has outgrown, a decision condemned in the casebooks and safely confined to the eugenics era. This Article argues that the commemorative posture mistakes condemnation for repudiation. Buck has never been overruled, and the governing premise it approved remains operative. The decision is best understood not as a narrow sterilization case but as a foundational one. It authorized what this Article terms anticipatory regulation, the use of disability or disability-related dependence as grounds to control reproduction, parenting, and family formation in advance rather than providing the support that would make family life possible.

A century later, anticipatory regulation takes two forms. Preventive regulation acts on forecasts of disability-related risk or incapacity, and it operates today in reproductive health care, where clinicians and guardians steer disabled people away from pregnancy, and in the family policing system, where predictions of unfitness substitute for findings of harm. Conditional regulation works through categorical presumptions about dependency, embedded in public benefits rules that force disabled people to choose between marriage and the income, health coverage, and personal assistance on which independent life depends. The vocabulary has shifted to that of medical risk, best interests, parental capacity, and eligibility, but the governing premise of eugenics, made explicit, endures.

This Article further contends that disability rights law, though crucial, cannot dismantle this structure, because the antidiscrimination model remedies discrete exclusions after they occur rather than securing the material conditions that keep disabled families from being drawn into these systems at all. Accordingly, the Article turns to disability reproductive justice, which measures the law by whether it provides disabled people the conditions to form and sustain families. One hundred years after Buck, honoring the centennial means ending what the decision authorized, a turn from prevention to provision.

Recommended!

To receive new posts from Legal Theory Blog by email, get a free subscription to Legal Theory Stack.

Lawrence Solum


Recent Posts