Tolson on Disenfranchisement in the Age of Callais

Franita Tolson (USC Gould School of Law) has posted The Graveyard Of Constitutional Rights: Legal, But Unconstitutional, Disenfranchisement In The Age Of Callais on SSRN.  Here is the abstract:

This Case Comment describes how the Supreme Court’s recent decision in Louisiana v. Callais fits within the hollowing out of four decades of voting rights jurisprudence. The Court’s approach in these cases has systematically subordinated the commitment to pluralistic democracy embodied by the Voting Rights Act of 1965 to a notion of colorblindness rooted in partisan advantage rather than constitutional principle. Rather than merely limiting the available remedies or deferring to the political branches, Callais fundamentally narrows the substantive protections afforded to minority communities by both Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act and the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments.

By relaxing constitutional and statutory constraints on discriminatory behavior by strategic state actors, Callais creates a category of “de minimis” constitutional and statutory violations. These violations have become effectively legal, despite their inconsistency with the principles embodied in the Reconstruction Amendments and the Voting Rights Act, because the Court has withdrawn meaningful mechanisms for identifying or remedying them. More broadly, Callais places Section 2 firmly within a constitutional framework that equates equal opportunity with race-based discrimination and places partisanship on the same constitutional plane as other legitimate state interests, which will be devastating to what remains of the Voting Rights Act.

Highly Recommended!

To receive new posts from Legal Theory Blog by email, get a free subscription to Legal Theory Stack.

Lawrence Solum