Bagchi on Interpersonal Duties in Political Context

Aditi Bagchi (Fordham University School of Law) has posted Interpersonal Duties in Political Context (American Journal of Jurisprudence, forthcoming) on SSRN.  Here is the abstract:

This article explores how interpersonal moral duties are inflected by political morality, and how their political dimension manifests in contract law. Many private law scholars, especially corrective justice theorists, regard private law as essentially apolitical because it is relational. I argue that political morality shapes interpersonal obligations pervasively by virtue of the duty to support just institutions. The latter duty can give rise to relational duties where individual rights-holders relate to the public justification behind a legal rule in the appropriate way.

When a legal rule contributes to a just social order, the duty to support just institutions generates system-supporting relational duties. When a system is unjust, the duty to support just institutions can generate a duty not to exacerbate systemic wrongs by exploiting other people. While a system-supporting duty directs us to protect vulnerable individuals through the existing system, a system-correcting duty directs us to protect individuals from the existing system. System-correcting duties are less typically reflected in legal rules than system-supporting duties. Still, private law makes space for some system-correcting duties. In particular, I will show how contract law recognizes system-correcting relational duties in its rules of formation, interpretation and excuse.

Highly Recommended!

To receive new posts from Legal Theory Blog by email, get a free subscription to Legal Theory Stack.

Lawrence Solum