Hurwitz on Data Portability

Justin (Gus) Hurwitz (University of Pennsylvania Law School) has posted The Unbearable Lightness of Data Portability: Three Lineages yet No Core (Washington Journal of Law, Technology & Arts, forthcoming) on SSRN.  Here is the abstract:

Data portability—the ability of users to access and transfer their personal data between digital services—has become a central feature of privacy and competition policy, appearing in the GDPR, the Digital Markets Act, state privacy statutes such as California’s CCPA and CPRA, and sector-specific regimes such as the CFPB’s open-banking rule. This Article argues that portability became attractive because it absorbed an older ideal of open systems, and that it turned unstable once that ideal was translated into law and asked to serve privacy, autonomy, interoperability, and competition at once. Three lineages converged on the word: a privacy and access lineage grounded in the European right to informational self-determination; a sector-specific service-portability lineage exemplified by telephone number portability, HIPAA, and open banking; and an open-systems lineage carrying the echo of the mantra that information wants to be free. That third lineage is the least examined. Its history has been recovered but never carried forward into the law it shaped. Contemporary regimes inherit all three without deciding which controls, producing uncertain scope, security tradeoffs, and weak or distorted competitive effects. The Article can press that claim because the evidence has finally arrived. Enough time has passed since Article 20 and the UK’s open-banking regime took effect that a substantial empirical literature now exists, and this Article offers the first comprehensive account of it: audits of what portability requests actually return, studies measuring entry and its distributional consequences, and formal models identifying when portability raises or lowers welfare. That record bears out the lessons of earlier efforts, from number portability to interconnection—cream-skimming, a persistent need for regulatory micromanagement, and entry at strategic margins rather than against incumbents. The Article closes with a limiting principle: portability mandates are most defensible where the data is standardized, operational, and tightly connected to interoperability, and least defensible where they make broad categories of user-generated content portable in the hope that access alone will answer structural competition concerns.

Recommended!

To receive new posts from Legal Theory Blog by email, get a free subscription to Legal Theory Stack.

Lawrence Solum