Lerer on Extinction of the Nineteenth Amendment

Ignacio Adrian Lerer has posted THE EXTINCTION OF THE NINETEENTH AMENDMENT: COMPUTATIONAL EVIDENCE FOR CONSTITUTIONAL MEMORY ERASURE on SSRN. Here is the abstract:

This study provides the first computational validation of Yale Law Professor Reva B. Siegel’s landmark thesis regarding the systematic erasure from of the Nineteenth Amendment constitutional jurisprudence.

Using RootFinder analysis-a novel computational tool designed to detect “extinct” constitutional doctrines-we examine 15 Supreme Court cases (1922-2023) where the Nineteenth Amendment is logically relevant to gender equality or voting rights claims. We document a 93.3% functional extinction rate: only one case (Leser v. Garnett, 1922) cites the Nineteenth Amendment as legal basis for decision. All modern cases (1971-2023) employ Fourteenth Amendment doctrine instead, despite the Nineteenth Amendment’s direct relevance.

Extinction is uniform across constitutional domains: 100% in gender discrimination cases (N=8), 100% in modern voting rights cases (N=4, 2008-2023), and 100% in reproductive rights cases (N=2).

Temporal analysis reveals immediate extinction following constitutional validation: the Nineteenth Amendment disappears from jurisprudence within 49 years of Leser (1922-1971), with no subsequent revival across 47 years of modern equal protection litigation.
Comparative analysis demonstrates this extinction is anomalous-the Second Amendment maintains 100% citation rate in gun rights cases, while the Fourteenth Amendment is cited in 100% of the same gender cases where the Nineteenth is ignored.

Critical case analysis of Frontiero v. Richardson (1973) reveals the mechanism of erasure: even sympathetic opinions acknowledge the Nineteenth Amendment historically but apply Fourteenth Amendment Due Process as legal basis, demonstrating constitutional memory loss despite formal amendment validity.

These findings validate Professor Siegel’s historical argument through quantitative methods and establish RootFinder as a viable tool for detecting systematic doctrinal extinction in constitutional law.

Very interesting. Recommended.