Sullivan on Trump v. United States

Barry Sullivan (Loyola University Chicago School of Law) has posted Trump’s Court, Nixon’s Constitution: Presidential Immunity And The Judicial Transformation Of American Government (Forthcoming Vol 35 Southern California Interdisciplinary Law Journal) on SSRN. Here is the abstract:

This Article looks in depth at the Supreme Court’s unprecedented decision in Trump v. United States, which, for the first time in American history, conferred immunity from criminal prosecution on former Presidents for “official acts” done in violation of the criminal law. The Court’s ruling is extraordinary on both doctrinal and institutional process grounds. Not only did the Court profoundly alter constitutional doctrine concerning presidential accountability, it did so in a way that effectively took ownership of the litigation, substituting its own arguments for those that the parties had made, and the lower courts had decided.

On a doctrinal level, the Article argues that the Trump Court’s grant of immunity to former Presidents for “official acts” that violate the criminal law lacks support in historical or legal precedent; marks a sharp break with the Watergate-era consensus that former presidents are accountable for their criminal abuses of power; and stretches the holding of Nixon v. Fitzgerald far beyond the private civil litigation context in which it arose and to which it was specifically limited by its authors. The Court makes no compelling argument for extending immunity to the far more serious area of criminal prosecution, nor for extending the so-called unitary executive theory to excuse the President’s use of federal officials to perform “official acts” that violate the criminal law.

On an institutional process level, the Court’s handling of the case was highly unusual. Chief Justice Roberts reportedly circulated a memorandum criticizing the decisions below and providing a roadmap for the Court’s ultimate opinion – something he did before certiorari was even granted or a single brief had been filed. Further taking over the case, the Court chose the question it intended to decide, discarded the parties’ formulations of the issues (which had formed the basis for the decisions below), and introduced arguments that had not been made by the parties. The Court also downplayed the serious danger to democratic government posed by President Trump’s concerted effort to remain in power after losing the 2020 election, minimized the violence of the January 6 storming of the Capitol, and fashioned a sweeping “rule for the ages” that not only shields the presidency from accountability, but invites the unremembering of a virtually unprecedented assault on American democracy.