Sunstein on Gender Equality & Freedom of Religion

Cass Sunstein has posted On the Tension between Sex Equality and Religious Freedom on SSRN. Here is the abstract:

When, if ever, is it legitimate for law to ban sex discrimination by religious institutions? It is best to approach this question by noticing that most of the time, ordinary civil and criminal law are legitimately applied to such institutions. For example, members of religious organizations cannot commit torts, even if the commission of torts is said to be part of their religious practices. Many people seem to accept what might be called an Asymmetry Thesis, which holds that sex equality principles may not be applied to religious institutions, whereas ordinary civil and criminal law may indeed be applied to them. This essay argues that the Asymmetry Thesis cannot be defended, and that much of the time, sex equality principles are properly applied to religious institutions. Discussion is also devoted to the controversial idea that facially neutral laws may be applied to religious institutions even if they have a severe adverse effect on religious practices.

And a bit more:

An important commonplace of democratic theory and practice might therefore be deemed the Asymmetry Thesis. According to the Asymmetry Thesis, it is unproblematic to apply ordinary civil and criminal law to religious institutions, but problematic to apply the law forbidding sex discrimination to those institutions. Thus it is uncontroversially acceptable to prevent priests from beating up women (or anyone else) as part of a religious ceremony, or to ban Orthodox Jews from assaulting Reform women rabbis (even if they are sincerely motivated by a religiously-founded idea of a male rabbinate); but it is often thought unacceptable to ban sex segregation in religious education,2 or to prohibit religious groups from excluding women from certain domains.

What is the source of this asymmetry? Can it be defended? I believe that in the end, there is no good defense of the Asymmetry Thesis, and that in many contexts, neither liberal ideals nor the Constitution should be taken to forbid government from banning sex discrimination by religious institutions.

This is a short but interesting effort by Sunstein.  Recommended.