David J. Arkush (Georgetown University Law Center) has posted Situating Emotion: A Critical Realist View of Emotion and Nonconscious Cognitive Processes for the Law on SSRN. Here is the abstract:
This Article attempts to clarify legal thinking about emotion in decision making. It surveys evidence from psychology and neuroscience on the extensive role that emotion and related nonconscious cognitive processes play in human behavior, then evaluates the treatment of emotion in three legal views of decision making: rational choice theory, behavioral economics, and cultural cognition theory. The Article concludes that each theory is mistaken to treat emotion mostly as a decision objective rather than a part of the decision making process and, indeed, to treat it as a force that mostly compromises that process. The Article introduces the view that emotion is a critical behavioral process that plays a role in most if not all decisions and is not readily amenable to accumulation or maximization. The Article discusses broad implications of this view for welfarist legal theory and policy generally and for an ongoing debate on risk regulation between behavioral economists and cultural cognition theorists. It also sketches potential applications for the law of employment discrimination, consumer protection, and criminal law.
And a bit more from the text:
Rather than suggest that people can be controlled by others as puppets, the goal of this Article is to outline a more realistic account of widely ignored or misunderstood forces in decision making, answering the question how we navigate the world in light of our inability to reason through most of the decisions that our environments demand of us and determining the proper place of emotion in theories of decision making. The answer appears to be that nonconscious, affective processes interact constantly with the environment and other biological processes (including more “cognitive” phenomena such as knowledge structures) to direct our attitudes and behavior.260 The evidence is beginning to suggest that automatic processes are capable of controlling most aspects of our behavior—that they even regulate our emotions261 and exercise self-control for us.262 Nonconscious affective processes are likely homeostatic, designed to promote selfpreservation.263 And higher-order emotions may be a complex, highly evolved version of the basic affective mechanism common to all life: approach and avoidance.264
This suggests that “preferences” and “welfare” are mistaken concepts, at least as commonly understood. “Preferences” are the name we give to mostvsalient and acceptable reasons we can identify for our behavior in variousvsituations, which we believe we have chosen. This is backward. Rathervthan mere objects of decision about which we reason and strategize, thevemotional forces that we call “preferences” are some of the very processesv that enable our bodies to interact with the environment, making decisions for us, in the absence of conscious monitoring and control. The environment constantly demands responses from us at a rate and level of complexity far greater than our conscious reasoning skills can accommodate, and affect and related nonconscious processes meet this challenge. Thus, in contrast to the economic assumption that choices are “preference-satisfying,”265 it would be better to view “preferences” as “choice-satisfying”: When the situation demands a behavioral response, the emotional processes that we call “preferences” provide it. As for “welfare,” unfortunately, there is little reason to assume that these processes maximize our happiness. The most we can say without entering a spiritual or religious discussion is that they help us survive in the evolutionary sense.
Thus, we come to an important distinction between “approach and avoidance” and “good and bad.” It is analogous to the difference Dan Gilbert and Kent Berridge have observed between “wanting” and “liking.”266 Not everything toward which our affective processes steer us is good, and not everything from which they steer us is bad. This is why affective processes should be thought of as approach-and-avoidance or go/no go processes267 instead of authentic judgments about, or windows into, “preferences” and “welfare.”
“Good” and “approach” can be misaligned for many of reasons. One important reason is that approach-and-avoidance processes did not evolve to make us happy, at least insomuch as happiness is unnecessary to evolutionary fitness. Rather, they evolved to help us navigate the world.268 Flashing lights automatically engage our attention but are not necessarily good for us. Their extensive use in environments carefully structured to extract money from people (casinos) is probably not welfare-enhancing. And just as insects fly into bug zappers, human children must be taught not to stare into the sun. (How are they taught? With warnings about an highly salient adverse consequence—the possibility of blindness.) Indeed, most traps that we set for other animals, from bug zappers to duck calls, employ approach responses harmfully. Our challenge is to recognize that have more in common with other species than we think.
This is a deeply interesting, and I think important article. Highly recommended. Download it while its hot!
