Issa Kohler-Hausmann (Yale University) has posted Ordinal Proportionality in Punishment: A Case against Capital Punishment for Child Rape Under the Eighth Amendment on SSRN. Here is the abstract:
This article argues that various theories of justice in punishment adhere to a principle of ordinal proportionality – relative grading of penalties in measure to the relative severity of the crimes for which they are imposed. Ordinal proportionality is a demand of both deterrence and retributive theories of justice; in addition it is a tenet well entrenched in the Supreme Court’s current Eighth Amendment jurisprudence. Under this principle the state cannot subject the crime of child rape to capital punishment because even a crime as horrendous as rape is not on par with murder in terms of harm and blameworthiness.
