Hafiz on an Institution-Focused Labor Exemption

Hiba Hafiz (Boston College – Law School) has posted An Institution-Focused Labor Exemption to Antitrust Law on SSRN.  Here is the abstract:

The rise of the gig economy, workplace fissuring, and the platform economy have fundamentally restructured the provision of labor services, defying traditional definitions of employer-employee relationships. In part because labor providers in this new economy offer services outside the traditional protections of labor and employment law, they are often the most vulnerable to the exercise of buyer power by purchasers of their labor, whether in the form of suppressed pay, slower wage growth, arbitrary or reduced hours, poor working conditions, algorithmic discrimination, or excessive monitoring and surveillance. But as workers providing labor in these decentralized and fractured work environments seek to exercise rights held by traditional “employees” to collectively negotiate their way out of these harms—most importantly, the right to organize, collective bargain, and strike—they face the threat of antitrust liability, injunctions, treble damages, and even criminal sanction.

Workplace restructuring and the growth of organizing among workers in the “new economy” has triggered renewed attention to the scope of antitrust law’s labor exemption. In a prominent decision, Confederación Hípica, the First Circuit held that organized jockeys were protected under the labor exemption regardless of their status as “independent contractors” or “employees,” stating that the Norris-LaGuardia Act was “intended to embrace controversies other than those between employers and employees.” But it left the question of the scope of those “other controversies” unexplained, establishing no limiting principle for when a “labor dispute” ceases to become a “dispute[] about wages for labor” and instead becomes a dispute “over prices for goods” or services.

This Essay delineates the tests—and their limiting principles—that have emerged in the case law and commentary that have sought to resolve uncertainties about the scope of the labor exemption’s application to purported “independent contractors.” Drawing from those sources, it outlines and rejects four proposed tests that seek to clarify that application—a labor and employment law test, a monopsony test, a bargaining leverage test, and an unfair methods of competition test. It then returns to the language and policy of the statutory labor exemptions themselves in the Clayton and Norris-LaGuardia Act to propose and defend an institution-focused labor exemption.

Recommended!

To receive new posts from Legal Theory Blog by email, get a free subscription to Legal Theory Stack.

Lawrence Solum