Download of the Week

The Download of the Week is Forum Shopping and the Infrastructure of Federalism by James E. Pfander.  Here is the abstract:

The
recent effort of environmentalists and others to secure progressive
social change at the state level enacts a familiar ritual in the
history of American federalism. Political actors who have found their
initiatives blunted at the national level have often turned to the
states. With the ebb and flow of political power between two parties
over time, arguments about the relative authority of federal and state
governments display far more expediency than principle, far more
mutability than predictability. States may be more or less progressive
than the national government, depending in good measure on the temper
of the times and the relative success of political movements in
particular states and regions of the country. If states do not
invariably produce progressive social legislation, why then should
progressives like Justice Brandeis defend state sovereignty? This Essay
suggests that the answer may lie in what it calls the infrastructure of
federalism, a series of doctrines that ensure the binding effect of
state law in our federal system of interstate litigation. By ensuring
the binding effect of state law, the infrastructure of federalism both
ensures that state legislatures remain relevant as centers of
policymaking and serves to encourage interstate forum shopping. Forum
shopping, in turn, may tend to advance the interests of plaintiffs in
litigation outcomes. While improving plaintiff win rates does not
directly advance progressive social values, forum shopping does tend to
ensure that firms operating throughout the nation must comply with
relatively more pro-consumer policies at the state level.

Highly recommended.