Feinstein on How People Want Agencies to Decide

Brian D. Feinstein (University of Pennsylvania – The Wharton School) has posted How People Want Agencies to Decide: Political Insulation, Public Voice, and Reason-Giving (Washington University Law Review, forthcoming) on SSRN.  Here is the abstract:

This Article examines the public’s views on how government should structure its decision-making across domains. In a conjoint experiment, approximately 7,200 participants read a vignette describing a proposed action in one of six domains: regulation, benefits distribution, surveillance, immigration enforcement, national security, or incarceration. Participants then chose between alternative combinations of procedures that varied randomly in who evaluates the proposal, the extent to which the public participates in the decision, whether and by whom costs and benefits are weighed, and whether the agency must give reasons.

These experiments find no popular constituency for presidential control. Instead, people tend to favor politically insulated officials over presidentially directed ones and prefer that agencies, rather than the White House, conduct cost-benefit analysis. Indeed, the single most-preferred feature is evaluation by career civil servants whom the president cannot fire at will—a striking result at a time when courts and the president are making executive-branch personnel more beholden to the White House. Participants also appreciate the notice-and-comment process—and would like to see it augmented to include outreach to under-voiced groups—and value agency reason-giving requirements.

These preferences generally hold across all six domains and for both Trump and Harris voters. Where law supplies different procedures for the state’s different faces, Americans have remarkably consistent views about how government should decide.

Highly Recommended!

To receive new posts from Legal Theory Blog by email, get a free subscription to Legal Theory Stack.

Lawrence Solum