Marouf & Pham on Data Equity as a Structural Principle of Federal Law

Fatma E. Marouf (Texas A&M University School of Law) and Huyen Pham (Texas A&M University School of Law) have posted The Law of Visibility (Vanderbilt Law Review, forthcoming) on SSRN.  Here is the abstract:

Debates over disaggregated demographic data have intensified in recent years, raising fundamental questions about the role of demographic visibility in federal statutory design. Across education, health care, housing, finance, and other domains, Congress has repeatedly embedded demographic data collection and reporting requirements into statutes designed to prohibit discrimination and reduce inequality. These provisions reflect a consistent legislative judgment: equality guarantees are difficult—if not impossible—to enforce when disparities cannot be observed. Yet, unlike privacy, transparency, security, and accuracy, equity has not been institutionalized as a cross-cutting principle of federal data governance. The result is a fragmented architecture in which demographic visibility appears program-specific and politically contingent, even though it performs a recurring and structural statutory function.

This Article contends that data equity—understood as the collection and analysis of sufficiently disaggregated data to identify and address disparities—should be recognized as a structural principle of federal law. That recognition understands that, in many statutory contexts, demographic visibility is the mechanism through which legislative commitments to equality gain practical effect. Structural recognition of data equity does not displace privacy or minimization norms, nor does it mandate limitless data collection. Rather, it clarifies that when Congress builds demographic comparison into statutory schemes, agencies may not suppress or dilute those systems without altering the operational design of the law itself. By making explicit this pattern of legislative design, the Article reframes contemporary disputes over demographic data—often cast as an ideological battle over “DEI”—as questions about statutory implementation, administrative constraint, and the conditions necessary for equality mandates to remain enforceable.

Recommended!

To receive new posts from Legal Theory Blog by email, get a free subscription to Legal Theory Stack.

Lawrence Solum