Joshua D. Blank (University of California, Irvine School of Law) and Leigh Osofsky (University of North Carolina (UNC) at Chapel Hill) have posted Agency Legal Explainers in the Age of AI (Administrative Law Review, forthcoming) on SSRN. Here is the abstract:
One of the core tasks of federal agencies is to translate and disseminate complex statutes and regulations in ways that the public can easily access and understand. Agencies discharge this duty by doing things like circulating fact sheets, creating website summaries, and using social media to explain the law. The recent advent of AI and third-party large language models raises an important, yet unexplored, question with respect to this project. How, if at all, should the rise of AI change the way that federal agencies communicate?
In this Article, we argue that these distillations of the law from agencies to the public, which we describe as “legal explainers,” play an important role in democratic governance. Legal explainers promote publicity and clarity, support the administration of the law, signal information about agencies’ views of the law to the public, and offer a valuable service to members of the public without cost. We argue further that when third-party AI sources generate information about the law, they often present the law incorrectly, answer questions inconsistently, fail to illuminate agency views on the relative importance of law and enforcement priorities, and provide varying degrees of quality depending upon whether users pay for service.
Against this backdrop, we develop a normative framework to serve as a guide for how agencies should communicate the law to the public in the age of AI. We argue that the recent proliferation of AI-generated (mis)information highlights the need for agencies to continue, and even intensify, their efforts to communicate the law to the public. Agencies should identify and promote their own descriptions of law as official agency legal explainers, use communication tools that are most effective in today’s information universe, target legal explainers toward groups that are most in need of reliable information about the law, and monitor and warn the public about issues with AI legal advice available through private sources. The more the public is awash with information about the law from other sources, the greater the government’s own obligation becomes to crystalize and communicate the law, to claim the essential link between government and the law that applies to the governed.
Recommended!
To receive new posts from Legal Theory Blog by email, get a free subscription to Legal Theory Stack.
Lawrence Solum
