Pryor Update, Version 2.0 My

Pryor Update, Version 2.0
My post entitled Catholic Doctrine and the Obligations of Judges in Abortion Cases: A Comment on the Pryor Nomination is only one of several reactions to Hugh Hewitt’s Weekly Standard column The Catholic Test. On HughHewitt.com, Hewitt responds to his critics: “The only defense of the anti-Catholic bigotry of Senate Democrats opposing William Pryor is invective, and so there has been plenty of invective spewing out from the usual suspects,” referring to Legal Theory Blog, among others. Hewitt also characterizes his opponents as “the frenzied left.”
Today, Hewitt has another column in the Weekly Standard, The Catholic Test, Part 2. And here is a taste:

    [T]he genuine problem with the Democrats’ position [is that] [t]heir test falls inevitably on Catholics who are faithful to the Catechism, and that faithfulness can be inferred from other behaviors without a question ever being asked and answered. Truly, can it possibly escape the notice of Leahy’s crowd that a nominee is a daily communicant? Does it really seem possible that the minority staff on the Judiciary Committee draws no conclusions from the religious practices revealed in FBI background reports? If a nominee to the appellate bench declares himself a faithful Catholic, trying to conform his or her life to the teachings of the Roman Catholic Church, isn’t a filibuster inevitable?

    This inevitable blackball is what I believe triggered Bishop Chaput’s denunciation, as well as the elite media’s avoidance of his denunciation. It is damned unpleasant to talk about such things, just as it was unpleasant to talk about who could and could not join certain clubs, and who could and could not eat in certain restaurants, and who could or could not attend certain universities. Bigotry is unpleasant stuff.

But the important question is: “What test is being imposed?”

    Are all anti-abortion nominees excluded from the bench?

    Or is it that all nominee’s who believe Roe was wrongly decided that are being excluded?

    Or is it all nominees who believe Roe can and should be circumvented by lower-court judges?

    Or all nominees who have opposed Roe with strong and harsh rhetoric (as Pryor allegedly has)?

    Or something else?

In order to determine whether an inappropriate litmus test has been imposed, we need to know what that test is. Part of the problem, I suspect, is that Democrats haven’t been very precise in stating their reasons for opposing Pryor, but precision is required for meaningful debate. I honestly don’t know why individual Senators oppose Pryor–at the requisite level of precision required for meaningful analysis, but I do think it is highly unlikely he is opposed simply because he is pro-life, for the reasons indicated in this report:

    [A] spokesman for the Judiciary Committee’s ranking Democratic members called such charges “despicable.” David Carle, press secretary for Sen. Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.), said both anecdotal evidence and reason suggest many pro-life Catholics have already been confirmed to federal judgeships with Democratic support. The committee doesn’t keep records on the religious affiliations of judgeship nominees, Carle said in a telephone interview, but “it stands to reason, of the 145 Bush nominees that have been confirmed so far, that many of them are Christians, that many of them are Catholics. Presumably, many if not all of them are pro-life Republicans.”

But just because Pryor is not opposed because he is pro-life does not mean that he is opposed for appropriate reasons. I hope to say more about this in the next few days. In the meantime, here is a roundup of the usual suspects (i.e. of reactions to Hewitt & the issue in general):

This is the first occasion upon which Legal Theory Blog has been categorized with “the frenzied left.”

Update: Hewitt emails and indicates that he had not intended to lump me with the “frenzied left.” Whew! That was a close call!

And don’t forget, check out this very thoughtful analysis of the moral obligations of a Catholic judge on legal theory annex.