Yet More on Teaching and Scholarship

Orin Kerr has a very good post entitled Legal Scholarship and "the Canon" at OrinKerr.com, which quite properly questions the empirical foundation for my claim that immersion in the canon–which is required of younger teachers–leads to a parallel immersions in canon-focused scholarship.  Also, Peter Spiro has a post entitled International Legal Scholarship and the Lack of a Canon, in which he observes that not all fields of law have a canon, and makes the further claim that there is no canon in international law:

    There isn’t a canon in international law, or at least it’s a very thin one (or alternatively a thick one under impossible and obvious stress), and it means that anything goes. Teaching can’t help but be a plus in that case, because you get the raw materials without the strictures of received wisdom. Teaching IL almost begs the teacher to come up with her own organizing principle; it forces you to think from scratch. And where there’s less of a canon, it’s less likely that there are powerful individuals who have a vested interest in it and who are looking to enforce orthodoxies through appointments and tenure decisions. This also allows for more imaginative and foundational scholarship (in a way that does have generational implications).

What a marvelous and hopeful thought!  It actually makes me want to work in IL!  And I must admit that I was thinking of the core of the law school currciulum–subjects like contracts, property, procedure, constitutional law, administrative law, tax, etc.–when I asserted that intensive preparation for teaching focuses one on the "canon."
Read Kerr and Spiro!