Dan Solove & Ann Bartow have had a nice exchange on Solove’s A Taxonomy of Privacy. Here are the links:
Bartow’s A Feeling of Unease About Privacy Law
Solove’s A Reply to Ann Bartow’s Response to A Taxonomy of Privacy
Here is a snippet from Bartow:
In one sense, the ultimate test of the value of [Solove’s] undertaking will be in how widely Solove’s taxonomy is referenced and adopted by ac-tors within the legal community. Yet because it is fashioned as a law review article, rather than a more efficiently perusable treatise, its at-tractiveness to jurists and practicing attorneys may be limited.6 It is arguably pitched most directly at other privacy law scholars, a great number of whom are quoted and cited by Solove within the text. It is certainly possible that it will prove a useful conceptual tool for future research efforts. However, independent-minded contrarians that we tend to be, it seems unlikely that too many legal scholars will uncriti-cally adhere to Solove’s taxonomy on any sort of consistent or whole-sale basis. As Solove expressly observes, privacy law is “fragmented and inconsistent,”7 and it is unlikely to smoothly merge into a coher-ent whole even with Solove’s best efforts at taxonomy construction. What Solove could accomplish someday, given his wide-ranging knowledge of privacy law, is a catalog of powerful, compelling reasons why the legal system should care about privacy violations more than it currently appears to.
