Yu on Anticircumvention

Peter K. Yu (Michigan State University College of Law) has posted Anticircumvention and Anti-anticircumvention (Denver University Law Review, Vol. 84, 2006) on SSRN. Here is the abstract:

In today’s debate on digital rights management (DRM) systems, there has been a considerable divide between rights holders, their investors and representatives on the one hand and academics (usually liberal academics), consumer advocates, and civil libertarians on the other. These two groups often talk past each other, each bringing with them their own doomsday scenarios. Unfortunately, neither side has sufficient empirical evidence to support its position. Nor is it able to disprove its rivals’ position once and for all. As the economy grows, the debate intensifies, and the divide between the two sides becomes wider. Today, there has emerged an urgent need to find common ground between both sides.

Published as part of the Inaugural Summit on Intellectual Property and Digital Media, Part I of this article examines the positions taken by both the proponents and critics of DRM systems and related laws. Part II then focuses on anticircumvention laws, highlighting their harms at both the domestic and international levels. This Part contends that an unbalanced international anticircumvention regime is more harmful than its domestic counterpart and encourages less developed countries to be more cautious about whether they should ratify the WIPO Internet Treaties and how they should implement those treaties. Part III concludes with four observations, which I hope will provide some insight into the development of the next generation of DRM systems and the accompanying legal regime that supports these systems.