Tamanaha on “Law as a Means to an End”

Brian Tamanaha is blogging about Law as Means to an End on Prawfsblawg.  Here is a taste from his first post in a series:

Beginning with Bentham and von Jhering, and taken further by Holmes, Pound, and the Legal Realists, reformers challenged this longstanding view, arguing that law is an instrument to serve the social good.  Briantamanaha

In the course of the twentieth century, this view took hold, but with a twist.  The instrumental view of law swept the legal culture, while people lost faith in the notion of the social good–either no longer believing that is there is a common social good, or that we can ever agree on what it is.

A pervasively held instrumental view of law in a context of sharp group-based disagreement leads to a Hobbesean struggle of all-against-all within the legal order and over the legal apparatus itself.  In one arena after another, from the practice of law, to judges and judging, to legislation and administration, individuals and groups attempt to seize control of the law and to use it as an instrument to advance their own or their groups’ agendas or interests–wielding the law as a coercive weapon against others.

I am really looking forward to Tamanaha’s posts.