Kornhauser & Takeda on Joint & Several Liability and Settlement

Lewis A. Kornhauser (New York University – School of Law) and Keith T. Takeda have posted N-Defendant Litigation and Settlement: The Impact of Joint and Several Liability on SSRN. Here is the abstract:

This article generalizes the analysis of settlement under joint and several liability from lawsuits involving one plaintiff and two defendants to those involving n≥2 defendants. We demonstrate that, depending upon the correlation of outcomes among the defendants, but regardless of the distribution of liability shares, joint and several liability may encourage plaintiffs to select some defendants for litigation while settling with those remaining. In particular, under joint and several liability, when each defendant is grouped with others sharing correlated outcomes, and the plaintiff’s probability of success against any defendant is sufficiently high, we show that the plaintiff prefers to litigate against a single defendant from each group to any other strategy profile. Because this preference can be characterized as both encouraging litigation and encouraging settlement, and because of the contingency of the effects of joint and several liability on the structure and level of correlation of the defendants’ outcomes, it is not sensible to characterize joint and several liabilty generally as either encouraging or discouraging litigations as in past literature.