Over at Law.com, there is a brief story on the panel discussion re blogs and legal scholarship at the University of Santa Clara. A taste:
When does a blog become legal scholarship? When it’s tedious and full of footnotes, right?
Joking aside, many in the legal world wonder whether bloggers who spend a great deal of time and effort making their sites illuminating and entertaining deserve the same recognition as authors who publish in legal journals. A group of practicing attorneys, academics and a judge — several of whom are active legal bloggers — got together earlier this month at Santa Clara University to discuss that question.
Panelist Lawrence Solum, a professor at the University of Illinois College of Law and author of the popular Legal Theory blog, said it was like comparing apples to oranges: Blogs and journal articles are simply two different ways to communicate ideas.
"What blogs represent is a change in communications technology," Solum said. "The blog is just an engine; it can create any kind of content."
Nonetheless, professors who put a lot of work into formulating quality blog posts should not be regarded by their universities as less productive at publishing, he said.
"The idea that you wouldn’t ‘count’ publication on the Internet strikes me as ultimately sort of silly," Solum said. "It’s inevitable that you’ve got to give recognition to things that are published online."
One important difference, Solum noted, is that legal blogs often address active law practitioners and reflect or give advice on current events, whereas journal articles tend to pick through matters of legal policy.
For a fuller statement of my views, see Blogging and the Transformation of Legal Scholarship.
