Khan on the Resoration of Pakistan’s Chief Justice

Ali Khan (Washburn University – School of Law) has posted Nine Notes on the Restoration of Pakistan’s Chief Justice (JURIST FORUM (May-July, 2007)) on SSRN. Here is the abstract:

This article consists of legal commentaries written in support of restoring the Chief Justice of Pakistan, who was sent on forced leave on March 9, 2007. These commentaries were written to clarify legal and constitutional points that arose during the hearing before the Supreme Court. They also discuss the impact of Pakistani lawyers’ protests on the outcome of the case. In July 2007, a unanimous Supreme Court of 13 Justices declared that the President’s Order to suspend the Chief Justice is “ultra vires of the Constitution . . . and passed without lawful authority.” Three Justices held that the President has the constitutional authority to file a reference. However, the Court unanimously set aside both the orders of the President and the Supreme Judicial Council to restrain the Chief Justice from acting as a judge of the Supreme Court. It is unclear whether these commentaries influenced the lawyers involved in the case or whether these commentaries were read or not read by Justices of the Supreme Court.