Schroeder on Agent-Relative Value

Mark Schroeder has posted ‘Teleology, Agent-Relative Value, and ‘Good’.’ on the Internet.  Here is an abstract:

Agent-Relative Teleology is widely supposed to be a theory that can yield the deeply attractive features of consequentialism without being subject to deep structural counterexamples like those having to do with predictions about agent-centered constraints and special obligations. But this, I think, is deeply mistaken. Though ART has the right structural features to be consistent with constraints and special obligations, it is not at all obvious that it retains the deeply attractive features of consequentialism. That it does so has been taken for granted, but as I demonstrate in this paper, it is a thesis whose defense would require substantial footwork. In this paper I show not only that such footwork is needed, but that it has not been done, and that it is highly plausible that it cannot be done. Among other things, I show that it is unpromising to think that the ART-ists’ claims about what is good-relative-to whom are independently plausible, and that there is no uncontroversial distinction between agent-relative and agent-neutral value to which ART-ists can appeal in explaining why their theory is attractive. Most surprisingly, I provide a general argument that ART cannot avoid the putative paradox of deontology, the very feature for which ART has always been generally assumed to be deeply attractive.