Check out Tom Bell’s Reforming the USN&WR Law School Rankings . Here’s a taste:
USN&WR should commit now to publishing corrections to any inaccuracies it discovers in the data it uses to rank law schools. It should do so at all events, given that students use the rankings to make very important decisions. It can do so easily, too; it need only update its website. Yet USN&WR has thus far failed to correct the erroneous data it used to (mis)rank the University of Florida College of Law and Baylor University School of Law. For shame!
Perhaps USN&WR does not want to publicly acknowledge that its law school rankings sometimes contain errors, fearing that to do so would decrease the credibility of its rankings and, ultimately, its profits. Consumers will eventually discover the errors, though. Better that USN&WR should correct the rankings when necessary and thereby reassure its customers that it sells the best data available.
