Law Review Rankings

Good Advice from Charles Sullivan on Concurring Opinons:

In short, I believe that, when engaged in window shopping during the Spring and summer submission seasons., both the submission strategy and the expedite strategy are pretty much dictated by where a particular review’s law school falls on the US News scale. There is almost no concern with whether a review is better (or worse) than its home law school, nor any effort to consult studies such as Professor Brophy’s. To the extent that this view pervades legal academia, and I am confident it does, other rankings of law reviews are exercises in futility: if suppliers of “content” (sometimes still called scholarship), follow the USNews hierarchy, law reviews will have their choice of articles pretty much in that order. Unless the student editors screw up pretty badly (and maybe even if they do), the "best" scholarship will continue to be published in the "best" journals, and the "best" journals will continue to be those associated with the "best" schools, all as determined by US News.

I agree with most of this, with the following caveats: (1) the best journals frequently publish scholarship of dubious quality–especially when the work is interdisciplinary in nature; (2) the best journals frequently do not publish high quality scholarship that lacks proxy indicators of quality, e.g. that is written by someone at a lower tier law school or by a younger scholar–there is a huge random factor for placement in these categories; (3) if we replaced "best" with "prestigious", then Sullivan’s observations would be pretty much on the money.  And to the extent that prestige correlates with quality, his claims are roughly accurate.