Darian Ibrahim (University of Arizona) has posted The Board as a Collective Body or a Collection of Individuals: Implications for Director Liability on SSRN. Here is the abstract:
How should we conceive of a corporate board: as a collective body, or as a collection of individuals? And what practical consequences flow from our conception? The high-profile ‘Disney’ case, just decided by the Delaware Supreme Court, flagged a critical yet overlooked issue in corporate law that goes to the very heart of the board’s nature. That is, when directors are sued for breaching their fiduciary duties, should courts determine their liability collectively, where all directors stand or fall together, or individually, where some directors may be liable but others not liable? This choice of assessment procedure can mean the difference between a director’s liability and her exoneration, and thus carries significant financial implications for directors, shareholders, insurers, and attorneys. It may also deepen our understanding of the nature of boards on a theoretical level. Although ‘Disney’ flagged the choice of assessment approach as an issue, it did not adequately address it. Surprisingly, given the issue’s interesting theoretical underpinnings and practical importance, neither has any other court or academic. Working from what is essentially a blank slate, this article proposes the criteria by which the whole board and individual director assessment approaches should be compared, and then applies those criteria to the three different types of fiduciary duties claims that shareholders can bring (assuming that after ‘Disney’, a "duty of good faith" exists in at least some form). It concludes with a split decision: by recommending that courts select the individual director approach in duty of loyalty and good faith cases, and the whole board approach in duty of care cases. For the most part, these recommendations track the limited case law on the issue. A collective/individual focus that shifts depending on context also reveals that, on a theoretical level, boards are properly conceived of as both collective bodies and a collection of individuals.
