Weatherall on CopynormsCopynorms are informal

Weatherall on Copynorms

    Copynorms are informal social attitudes about the rightness or wrongness of duplicating material that is copyrighted.
    Kim Weatherall has a very good post on copynorms. Here is a taste:

      [N]owadays, copyright affects many more individual’s freedom to do what they like with things they have bought (computers, CDs, MP3 players, etc). Convincing Jo Public that these kinds of constraints should be observed is a much taller order than convincing him that CD-Factories and Book Factories shouldn’t be allowed to do what they like and copy what they like.

      This is a line that Randy Barnett emphasises in his review (pdf doct) of Lessig’s Future of Ideas. In his review, Randy argues that

        [T]he propertization of cyberspace is a restriction upon private property in physical space and upon the free market as much as any other regime of property regulation.

        False claims of property rights are the enemy of genuine property rights … Time-Warner and Microsoft and counless other remote corporations now claim to own a piece of your PC, your LPs and CDs, your VCR, your DVD player, and your MP3 player. The courts and Congress have bought their claims. That is very bad.

      Actually – this is even more literally true than even Randy Barnett perhaps realises. After all one argument by Sony in Sony v Stevens was that RAM copies – temporary copies in a computer’s memory – were “reproductions in material form” under the Copyright. Had this argument succeeded (which it did not), it would almost literally mean that a little bit of your computer – while the RAM copy persisted – was “owned” by the copyright owner. Weird… Anyway, back to Randy:

        By invading our homes and businesses to tell us what to do with what is ours, and what of ours we can freely trade with each other without going to jail, IP is as much a restriction on classical liberal property rights as wage and price controls or designating historic districts that restrict how you can remodel your house. All the benefits Lessig sees from the internet commons are a product of private persons applying their minds to devise new uses for what is theirs and trading those possessions with others.”

      I agree with Solum that enraging – and dismissing – elite opinion is bad strategy for the record industry. But enraging a few lawyers is one thing – directly implicating individuals (who do not, in general, like to be thought of as thieves, especially when they are using their own stuff – computers and CDs and things) is even more important. and an even bigger obstacle directly in the way of any RIAA-desired norm shift.

    Weatherall is absolutely right to point us to Barnett’s discussion of the relationship between IP and traditional property. Indeed, the biggest possible mistake that copyright holders could make would be to sucessfully lobby for legislation permitting them to engage in self-help (sabotaging computers that act as file servers for unauthorized mp3 files). Backlash would be too mild a word.

And by the way, you may also want to take a gander at Weatherall’s most recent post Jack Balkin woz ‘ere.