Falk on High Politics
Reacting to my post from this past Sunday, A Neoformalist Manifesto, Economist Jonathan Falk writes:
- I found your Sunday piece well reasoned. In responding to Balkin as you have, however, I think you miss an important point about “high politics,” namely the extent to which an eschewal of high politics in the judiciary makes things less contentious in the long run as the people’s directly elected representatives are forced to hash these things out. You are quite correct to surmise that a judiciary which did not require women’s equality was quite likely to find itself with an ERA to confront. But more than that, the mere passage of an ERA eliminates much of the contentiousness associated with its creation. The perfect example here is Roe v. Wade. While I have seen lots of opinions that the result of Roe v. Wade was correct, I have never seen a justification of the logic of the opinion itself. (Remember, I’m just an economist, so I could have missed it.) The short-circuiting of the people which such a decision represents, however, guarantees that it will continue to rankle. There is no question that abortion would be a far less divisive issue today had the Supreme Court kept their noses out of the issue, i.e. putatively upheld every restriction AND every liberalization.
The problem, of course, is twofold. First, judges are impatient and unwilling to wait for the fullness of time to justify their views. (I ignore the substantial number of times when the fullness of time rejects their views.) Second is the problem that judges are expected to do justice in the case before them. It seems unsatisfactory to say to Roe, “Well, I wish you could have an abortion, and a proper political system which recognized your liberty should allow you to have an abortion, but my hands are tied.” After all, it seems to be such a short step from the “should” in the previous sentence to “will,” given that the judge has the power to make “should” into “will.” But it isn’t. What is really needed here is another judgely virtue which doesn’t make your list: humility — that even beyond stare decisis, there are decisions that are not theirs to make.
