Tan on the US-China Contest for Scientific Talent

Albert Tan (University of Groningen, Faculty of Law; Interdisciplinary Analysts) has posted Binding Promises in the US-China Contest for Scientific Talent on SSRN.  Here is the abstract:

Governments that recruit scientists also hold powers to interrupt a researcher’s career or to stop a researcher leaving the country. This article asks how that combination affects competition for scientific capacity, and it answers by treating recruitment in the United States and China as a problem of credible commitment. A scientist who moves makes investments whose value depends on continuity of status, meaning continued permission to do the work, and on freedom to leave. A change to either can cut the value of an appointment once the move is made. American litigation in 2025 and 2026 shows the executive changing these conditions and the courts limiting the changes. China recruits abroad while restricting the exit of defined groups, and a decree in force since September 2026 adds a ground based on industrial and technological security. Published studies of scientific mobility document costs from political pressure on researchers, and the recruitment effects of these legal rules have yet to be measured. Procedural safeguards can strengthen recruitment where researchers make large investments tied to one destination and have credible alternatives elsewhere, though the outcome also turns on funding and institutional quality, and on the researcher’s citizenship. The article proposes domestic protection for continuity of status and timely review of security decisions, coordinated through existing international instruments.

Recommended!

To receive new posts from Legal Theory Blog by email, get a free subscription to Legal Theory Stack.

Lawrence Solum