Nogueira on Tax Nexus and Its Vis Expansiva

João Félix Pinto Nogueira (International Bureau of Fiscal Documentation; Law School – Catholic University of Portugal (UCP); University of Cape Town (UCT)) has posted Tax Nexus and Its Vis Expansiva: How the Collapse of Information and Enforcement Barriers Fuelled the Nexus Explosion on SSRN.  Here is the abstract:

This article investigates why the tax nexus expanded so rapidly in recent decades and, more specifically, whether this expansion can be understood as a consequence of the weakening of informational and enforcement constraints that traditionally limited this exercise.

The scholarly literature has devoted considerable attention to the competing economic, technological, legal and normative considerations invoked to justify the expansion of the tax nexus, particularly in cases in which taxing rights are asserted over persons, property, conduct or circumstances lacking a territorial-physical connection with the taxing State. This article takes a different approach. It argues that although these considerations help explain why States have sought to expand the nexus, they do not, by themselves, explain how such an expansion became practically possible. The key determinant of the expansion lies in international administrative cooperation and, more specifically, in the progressive weakening of the informational and enforcement constraints that had previously limited the exercise of taxing rights beyond the State’s territorial-physical reach. International administrative cooperation thus changed the practical conditions under which sovereignty could be exercised and provided the conditions necessary for the expansion of the tax nexus, particularly in relation to the market-based nexus.

The article, therefore, advances a two-dimensional account of nexus expansion. In addition to considerations relating to digitalisation and globalisation, tax competition, fairness, and economic allegiance, it identifies changes in international administrative cooperation, particularly the weakening of informational and enforcement constraints, as a conditio sine qua non for understanding how that expansion became practically possible.

This revised two-step understanding of the expansion requires a word of caution. Given that the latest expansions of the source nexus require cooperation from the State where the taxpayer, information, or assets are physically located, such cooperation should be seen as the infrastructure that enables this exercise. And such cooperation rests on reciprocal political commitments that can be revised at any time.

Tax nexus expansion is, in a certain way, a continuation by other means of the (inherent) State impulse to extend power and sovereignty, now pursued through tax claims rather than territorial claims. Accordingly, an expansion perceived as an excessive intrusion into another State’s fiscal sovereignty risks eroding the very cooperative infrastructure that sustains it. A paradox that may ultimately limit how far the tax nexus can expand in practice.

Recommended!

To receive new posts from Legal Theory Blog by email, get a free subscription to Legal Theory Stack.

Lawrence Solum