Mazzone & Amar on Mootness in Little v. Hecox

Jason Mazzone (University of Illinois College of Law) & Vikram D. Amar (University of California, Davis – School of Law; University of Illinois College of Law) have posted Open Letter To The Supreme Court Urging Adherence To Settled Mootness Principles In  Little V. Hecox (2025 U. Ill. L. Rev. Online 160 (2025)) on SSRN. Here is the abstract:

In Little v. Hecox, one of the most-watched cases of the Supreme Court’s 2025-26 term, the cert petition granted by the Court presents the question of whether laws that seek to protect women’s and girls’ sports by limiting participation to women and girls based on sex violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Developments in the case after the Supreme Court granted review render the case now moot under longstanding doctrine. But the state petitioners resist that conclusion and ask the Supreme Court to craft a new exception to mootness and to decide the case on the merits. This essay shows why doing so would be contrary to past caselaw and inconsistent with Article III’s limitation of federal jurisdiction to cases and controversy, and would significantly distort federal litigation and adjudication. In Hecox (and other cases) the Court should stick to a basic principle: moot is moot.

Recommended.