David S. Schwartz (University of Wisconsin Law School) has posted Reply to Professor Rothstein (100 Geo. L.J. Online 16 (2012)) on SSRN. Here is the abstract:
Responding to a critique of A Foundation Theory of Evidence, 100 Geo. L.J. 95 (2011), this essay argues that plausible but improbable assertions of fact cannot be relevant evidence, which requires that an offered fact be both relevant and evidence.
Recommended. Links to the prior papers in the abstract.