Bohannan on Construing the Copyright

Bohannan on Construing the Copyright Act
Christina Bohannan (University of Iowa, College of Law) has posted Construing the Copyright Act after Eldred on SSRN. Here is the abstract:

    In Eldred v. Ashcroft, the Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of the 1998 Copyright Term Extension Act (CTEA), which extended the copyright term of both new and existing works by twenty years, despite the lack of incentive that such a retroactive term extension would provide for the creation or dissemination of new works. Although the CTEA is perhaps the most notorious example of rent-seeking by special interests in copyright law to date, a majority of the Court dismissed the petitioners’ constitutional challenges without any mention of the influence that special interest groups had over its enactment.

    The Court’s decision was disappointing to many, but it was hardly surprising. Because the CTEA’s language extending the copyright term was clear and unambiguous, there was no issue of statutory construction facing the Court C the issue was strictly constitutional, and the Court rarely strikes down economic laws like intellectual property statutes. Indeed, to do otherwise would thwart well-established constitutional principles including Congress’s lawmaking power under Article I as well as separation of powers inherent in the structure of the Constitution. Thus, even public choice scholars who advocate more exacting judicial review of special-interest legislation often argue that it goes too far to strike down such legislation on constitutional grounds.

    In this paper, Professor Bohannan argues that whether or not the Eldred Court was correct in ignoring special interest influences in its constitutional analysis of the CTEA, courts should not ignore those influences when dealing with statutory construction of other provisions of the Copyright Act. Special-interest influence over the Copyright Act has been pervasive over the past few decades, and the general trend in copyright law has been an expansion of the rights of copyright owners at the expense of public access to copyrighted works. This tension between private and public interests in copyright law often presents itself in copyright infringement cases as a statutory ambiguity between private-and public-regarding provisions in the Copyright Act. Professor Bohannan argues that, where possible, such statutory ambiguities in the interpretation of the Copyright Act should be resolved by a rule of statutory interpretation that takes into account the private- or public-interest nature of the ambiguous provisions. The paper identifies ambiguities between public-and private-interest provisions in the Act and offers several theories of statutory interpretation in support of resolving such ambiguities by construing the private-interest provisions narrowly and the public-interest provisions broadly.